What’s More Important For Weight Loss Diet Or Exercise

What’s More Important For Weight Loss Diet Or Exercise

What’s more important for weight loss – diet, exercise or SLEEP?

Ask almost any fitness expert and theyll tell you that both diet and exercise are important for losing weight. No doubt, both factors play a role in the process, but could one possibly be more effective than the other?

Its likely.

A new report published in the British Journal of Sports Medicine found that exercises impact on obesity is minimal.

The main point: while exercise is important for preventing diseases like diabetes, heart disease and dementia, when it comes to preventing obesity and metabolic issues diet plays a significantly larger role.

Dr. Aseem Malhotra, a London cardiologist who contributed to the report told the BBC that eating less was of more importance than exercise for an obese person that wants to lose weight.

“My biggest concern is that the messaging that is coming to the public suggests you can eat what you like as long as you exercise, he said. That is unscientific and wrong. You cannot outrun a bad diet.”

In other words, many people commonly believe that if they exercise enough, they can eat less nutritious foods without suffering from any health consequences, but many scientific findings continue to debunk this misconception.

In fact, this particular report pointed to evidence which suggests that up to 40 percent of people with a normal body mass index will experience metabolic abnormalities like hypertension, heart disease and non-alcoholic fatty liver disease.

What does all of this mean for the average weight loss candidate, though?

Take A Walk Today Like Al Roker For Fitness Sake

Still, many people wrongly believe obesity is entirely due to lack of exercise when the fact is you cannot outrun a bad diet, researchers wrote in an editorial in the British Journal of Sports Medicine.

Pontzer agreed, noting were surrounded by processed foods with added oils and sugars that are designed and focus-group tested to affect our brains in ways that are almost addictive.

Here are more findings from his book:

Now Lets Do Some Math

Simply, losing weight is a math problem. In order to lose weight, you must create a caloric deficit. Basically, youre spending more calories than you are taking in. Sounds pretty straightforward, right? And exercise should help you reach that deficit too, right? Well, the answer isnt that easy. The human body is a complicated machine, and human behavior is even more complicated.

First of all, how many calories you burn each day is made up of four main parts: your basal metabolic rate , the energy you use in breaking down food, the energy you burn from non-exercise related mechanisms like didgeting, and physical activity. Physical activity usually only makes up about 10-15% of the calories you burn in a day.

If youre looking to 1 lb per week, your goal would be to create a deficit of 3500 calories per week. That means that an average person must create a deficit of 500 calories per day by eating less food, burning more calories through activity, or a combination of the two.

Now lets look at an example: a person who weighs 185 pounds would burn about 200 calories walking 30 minutes at a quick pace. So of the 500 calories deficit you need, a 30 minute walk could contribute to 200 calories.

You May Like: How Many Calories In A Keto Diet

Exercise Vs Diet: Which Is More Important For Weight Loss

Being sound is straightforward, correct? Eat less, move more. Thats anything but difficult to state, however reasonableness is one of the most significant things with regards to wellbeing and wellness. Proposals like this are cover articulations that dont address reasonablenessso all things considered, which is more significant? Diet, or exercise?

Truly, we should all eat more beneficial. Indeed, we should practice each day. There are interminable things we could do so as to be more beneficial, as sit less, eat more vegetables, eat less prepared food, or drink less liquor. However, they dont consider the truth of life: we are completely compelled by a limited measure of assets, for example, time, energy, self discipline, and cash. Suggestions that dont consider can undoubtedly cause us to feel like we are bombing our wellness and wellbeing objectives.

To give you a feeling of the significance of reasonableness, consider this ongoing meta-study , distributed in the Journal of the American Medical Association, which tried to sort out which diet works best? by taking a gander at the consequences of 59 individual examinations. These examinations included different wholesome proposals, for example, low-fat, low-carb, etc. Which of these proposals ruled lord? None. There were no significant contrasts between the weight control plans, and achievement was totally reliant on what the individual could stick to. At the end of the day, common sense ruled ruler.

Eating More Weighing Less

Want to lose weight? Whats more important, diet or exercise?

The really good news, as thousands of people at the Pritikin Longevity Center have discovered over the last four decades, is that we can eat plentifully nice big portions and lose weight. This scientifically documented approach is all about choosing foods that give us the most satiety per calorie, foods such as:

  • Fresh fruits
  • Water-rich whole grains like hot cereals and brown rice
  • Starchy vegetables like potatoes, corn, and yams
  • Legumes like black beans and pinto beans
  • Nonfat dairy, and
  • Lean animal foods like seafood, bison, and white poultry

Smart eating, sums up Dr. Kenney, is not about setting for less. Its about putting more good food on our plate.

Health Resort

Don’t Miss: What Is A Good Diet To Go On

Why Exercise Is More Important Than Weight Loss For A Longer Life

People typically lower their risks of heart disease and premature death far more by gaining fitness than by dropping weight.

  • Read in app

By Gretchen Reynolds

For better health and a longer life span, exercise is more important than weight loss, especially if you are overweight or obese, according to an interesting new review of the relationships between fitness, weight, heart health and longevity. The study, which analyzed the results of hundreds of previous studies of weight loss and workouts in men and women, found that obese people typically lower their risks of heart disease and premature death far more by gaining fitness than by dropping weight or dieting.

The review adds to mounting evidence that most of us can be healthy at any weight, if we are also active enough.

I have written frequently in this column about the science of exercise and weight loss, much of which is, frankly, dispiriting, if your goal is to be thinner. This past research overwhelmingly shows that people who start to exercise rarely lose much, if any, weight, unless they also cut back substantially on food intake. Exercise simply burns too few calories, in general, to aid in weight reduction. We also tend to compensate for some portion of the meager caloric outlay from exercise by eating more afterward or moving less or unconsciously dialing back on our bodies metabolic operations to reduce overall daily energy expenditure, as I wrote about in last weeks column.

Apply The : 20 Rule For Results

Have you read success stories of dramatic weight loss? At the forefront of the accomplishments of the people in these success stories are improved nutritional programs and diets. Some have shared the application of drastic food changes and also healthier methods of cooking and eating before starting an exercise program.

This began the journey of their success, and adding in the workouts was the bonus that made it all come together. It was important to master a healthy nutrition plan. These successful people also understood mastering a healthy nutrition plan as the largest role in being able to reach fitness goals.

It may be nice to think positive body changes can be made simply by exercising, but that’s far from the truth. Applying the 80:20 rule creates the difference and understanding food will be the major player in how you look. Finally, this is an easy foundation to approach body composition, but it is more complicated because stress, sleep, and genetics also plays a role. To really understand how all of these components affect the body, it is recommended to see a registered dietitian nutritionist.

Read Also: What Foods Are Restricted On Keto Diet

Is Nutrition More Important Than Exercise

You’ve heard the phrase “you can’t out-exercise a bad diet,” and this is the bottom line when it comes to maintaining a healthy body. Nutrition and exercise are both important parts of losing fat and gaining strength.

Nutritional habits will have a far greater impact on your body composition and physique goals than any other fitness component. When a combination of exercise and healthy nutrition are implemented is when successful body change happens.

We Need To Reframe How We Think About Exercise

Role of Diet & Exercise in Weight Loss What is More Important in Losing Weight – Dieting or Workout?

Obesity doctor Yoni Freedhoff has called for a rebranding of how we think of exercise. Exercise has staggering benefits it just may not help much in the quest for weight loss:

The evidence is now clear: Exercise is excellent for health its just not that important for weight loss. So don’t expect to lose a lot of weight by ramping up physical activity alone.

As a society, we also need to stop treating a lack of exercise and diet as equally responsible for the obesity problem in this country. Public-health obesity policies should prioritize fighting the over-consumption of low-quality food and improving the food environment.

Recommended Reading: Best Diet To Lose Pregnancy Weight

How I Like To View Exercise For Weight Loss

Use it as your guiding light.

Use it as a signal for you to stay on track with your diet.

I used to play badminton with my best friend – and after every session, he would want to go for a beer – which made no sense to me.

Yes. I enjoy Beer like the best of them.

But, I used to think to myself what was the point of slogging it out on a court for 90 minutes to then harm all of your recovery efforts with a couple of Beers.

I used the movement as a way of improving my willpower and my desire to keep my diet in a better place.

And if you can do that over time – you will then see the effects and benefits of weight loss as a result of your movement.

Because it will lead to better dietary choices.

It will reduce stress which will lead to better dietary choices.

It will help your Mental Health which will lead to better dietary choices.

But either way, you look at it, you are looking to use exercise to improve your dietary choices and create a better balance in your life in favour of your goals.

Looking At The Numbers: How To Lose 1 Pound

One of the most important things you need to consider is the amount of effort it requires to achieve a negative energy balance.

Your body loses weight when you are consuming fewer calories than you are burning. So, you have two options to reduce fat storage: eat fewer calories or increase the number of calories you are burning. When you are proactive about both of these efforts, then its easier to lose the weight more quickly.

If you look at the math, it requires a 3,500-calorie deficit to lose one pound of fat. You can reduce your calories over the course of a week or two to achieve their deficit. Or, increase your exercise to the point where you are burning more calories than normal.

The optimal solution is to find a balance between diet or exercise. For example, you might aim to burn 1000 calories through exercise in a few days. At the same time, be proactive with your meal planning to create a 2,500-calorie deficit in the meals you are eating. That will add up to a total deficit of 3,500 calories for the week which should be a pound of fat that you will lose.

Don’t Miss: No Sugar No Yeast Diet

Whats More Important For Weight Loss: Diet Or Exercise

So you want to lose weight, but all of your previous attempts have gotten you nowhere. Or you may have succeeded in losing some weight quickly, only to regain it just as fast. Maybe youve tried both exercise and dieting, but arent sure which is more effective.

While both diet and exercise are important contributors to weight loss, cutting calories promotes weight loss more effectively than increasing exercise. Its generally easier to lower your calorie intake than it is to burn more calories through increased exercise.

Creating A Caloric Deficit

Diet vs. Exercise: Which is better for weight loss?

According to experts, weight loss is achieved when you take in fewer calories than you burn. To shed one pound, you need to burn or have a caloric deficit of about 3,500 calories. Why 3,500? Because it is equal to about one pound of fat. To create this deficit, yes, you could try your hardest to burn that much during workouts, but it would be much easier to cut out calories than to run 10 miles a day, burning only 500-700 calories.

Read Also: 10 Day No Carb No Sugar Diet

Healthy Weight Loss Infographic

Consider what forms of weight loss are most effective in order to find a solution that’s right for you. Science of Weight Loss

If the actual weight increase was the same as what we predicted, that meant that food intake was virtually entirely responsible. If it wasnt, that meant changes in physical activity also played a role, explained lead author Boyd Swinburn, PhD., director of the World Health Organization Collaborating Centre for Obesity Prevention at Deakin University in Australia.

For the kids, it turned out that the predicted and actual weight gain matched exactly. The increases in calorie intake alone over the three decades explained the childrens weight gain.

For the adults, the average weight gain the researchers had predicted was nearly 24 pounds. The weight gain the American adults actually experienced was nearly 19 pounds.

All Diets Work If You Stick To Them

Thats hard to do, of course. Modern foods are too delicious and designed to be overeaten, Pontzer writes. When not sure exactly how much to eat, humans have evolved to err on the side of eating more.

But whether you choose low-carb, low-fat, vegan, intermittent fasting, Paleo or Mediterranean, whichever diet allows you to eat fewer calories over the long-term will help you lose weight.

Recommended Reading: Liquid Diet After Gallbladder Surgery

The Pitfalls Of Counting Calories

Our focus should not be on counting calories, a tactic many Americans try and fail at. And why wouldnt they? If youre counting calories and eating your regular diet , the only way you can cut calories is to cut food. Half of a burger. Half a bag of fries. Six potato chips. A sip of Coke. But think about it. By paring our food down to small portions like this, most of us are pulling back from the table still hungry. How long can this type of eating really last?

Trying to eat fewer calories from calorie-dense, low-fiber foods and calorie-dense beverages wont likely work in the long term because hungry people rarely continue to eat less as hunger rachets up. This is why it is important to change what we eat, and not just count calories, emphasizes Dr. Kenney.

Whats More Important For Weight Loss

Exercise Vs Diet | Which is better for weight loss?

You may have heard that losing weight is 80 percent nutrition and 20 percent exercise or that “abs are made in the kitchen”, but neither of these statements are completely true.

Losing weight or achieving a body goal is 100 percent commitment to a plan which consists of exercise and a healthy, calorie-restricted diet.

In fact, Olympian and owner of Roar Fitness London Sarah Linsday claims both exercise and diet are as important as each other.

No matter how much you work out or how heavy the weights you lift are, you need to eat the right amount of calories to stay healthy.

Sarah said: Diet is absolutely crucial. It doesnt matter what your goal is, you need to eat for optimal health and you should never compromise that.

READ MORE- How to longer: The cheap and simple daily dietary tip

Also Check: Weight Training Diet For Males

Is Diet More Important Than Exercise For Weight Loss

If youve ever been on a weight loss journey, its likely that youve been in an excruciating exercise class. The one where youre not totally enjoying yourself, but youre doing it in hopes of torching major calories.

Did you lose weight? Possibly! But how long did it take before the weight started creeping back, even while you were wearing yourself out with exercise? How long did it take before you stopped going to classes because you werent enjoying it anymore?

Working out more and more while combatting slowing metabolism as we age and other daily stressors just isnt sustainable, and it certainly isnt enjoyable. Something else has to give and be adjusted, rather than solely relying on exercise alone to address weight loss.

Prioritizing a healthy diet over calorie-crushing workouts is much more effective when it comes to losing fat. Hooray for whole foods!

Lets take a closer look at how to reach your weight loss goals the effective, easy, sustainable, and healthy way.

For Weight Loss Diet More Important Than Exercise Heres Why

For those planning to hit the gym to lose weight, take note. A new study suggests that diet is far more important than physical activity including walking, fidgeting and formal exercise. The reason is because exercising increases appetite especially with prolonged endurance exercise or with weight lifting that can ultimately sabotage the best of intentions, CNN reported.

People who lose weight gradually are more successful at keeping weight off, according to the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. About 10% of our calories are burned digesting the food we eat and roughly 10% to 30% are lost through physical activity, the study said.

It could not be more true. What you omit from your diet is so much more important than how much you exercise, nutritionist Lisa Drayer was quoted as saying to CNN. All of your calories in come from the food you eat and the beverages you drink, but only a portion of your calories out are lost through exercise, according to Drayer.

The average person — excluding professional athletes — burns 5% to 15% of their daily calories through exercise, said Alexxai Kravitz, Investigator at the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases in the US. It is not nearly equal to food intake, which accounts for 100% of the energy intake of the body, said Kravitz.

Follow more stories on and

Read Also: How Many Calories In Optavia Diet

Stay in Touch

To follow the best weight loss journeys, success stories and inspirational interviews with the industry's top coaches and specialists. Start changing your life today!

Related Articles